One of the government ministers I worked for in a former life used to say, “For every major political problem, there are at least five solutions that are, a) obvious and common-sense; b) quick and easy to implement; and c) absolutely the wrong thing to do from the perspective of the national interest.” His words often return to me when I hear Nigel Farage speak.
“We’ll take back control.” “We’ll scrap net zero.” “We’ll freeze immigration.” Farage’s promises have always had the knack of simplicity. They cut through complex issues with slogans that promise quick, easy answers to the frustrations many people feel. And that’s exactly why they’re so effective – and dangerous.
Farage’s ability to capture attention is undeniable. He’s a master of that. He understands anger and frustration, and turns them into punchy phrases that resonate deeply with people who rightly feel ignored by the political establishment. But apply even a modicum of scrutiny to his words and we immediately see the problem: these catchy promises too often conceal complexities – and consequences – that Farage conveniently sidesteps.
Take his flagship issue – immigration. Farage repeatedly promises a dramatic reduction or even a total freeze, tapping into genuine worries about public services and cultural cohesion. But what he never mentions is that the NHS, social care, and logistics sectors rely heavily on immigrant labour. A complete immigration freeze just isn’t realistic – it’s economic self-harm. Farage’s slogans don’t solve the problem; they merely exploit it.
His promise to scrap net zero follows the same pattern. On the surface, it appeals to people worried about high energy bills and taxes (hands up who’s not in that group…anyone?). Yet look deeper, and it becomes clear this policy would leave the UK lagging behind in a rapidly changing world economy, reliant on expensive fossil fuel imports, and vulnerable to environmental catastrophes like flooding and food shortages. Once again, Farage offers a simple fix that ignores inconvenient truths.
Then there’s his pledge to withdraw from the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). It sounds bold – asserting our national sovereignty over Johnny Foreigner – but Farage doesn’t disclose the reality: abandoning the ECHR risks stripping away basic protections that most British people value, such as rights to a fair trial, privacy, and freedom from arbitrary government interference. Do people really want to give up those things, especially now they can see what Farage’s best buddies are doing in the US right now?
Of course, none of this is new. As anyone connected to Open Britain knows all too well, Farage’s Brexit campaign set the template for grand promises that don’t hold up under scrutiny. Remember the £350 million promised weekly to the NHS on the side of that infamous red bus? About a nanosecond after the referendum results were in, Farage was already on the media distancing himself from the claim, calling it “a mistake.” Brexit was sold as a straightforward route to prosperity, freedom, and national pride, yet the reality has turned out to be far more complicated – and costly – for millions of ordinary Britons.
The pattern is clear: Farage uses caustic criticism and specious solutions to make headlines, wins applause from his cronies in the media and supporters who naively accept whatever he says without question, and then walks away when harsh reality bites. He isn’t accountable for the empty promises he sells; he doesn’t stick around long enough to deal with the fallout. And that leaves ordinary people – like you and me – to deal with the consequences.
So, what can we do about that? Well, we can start by asking more and better questions. We should never take ANY politician’s promises at face value, but that’s especially true where Nigel Farage is concerned. Whenever we hear a bold promise, we should stop and ask ourselves three questions:
– How would this actually work in practice?
– Who benefits most if we do this – and who pays the price?
– Why is this promise being made now, and who’s pushing it?
It’s understandable that ordinary people across the country are frustrated and want real change. The anger they feel at the failures of the establishment is justified. But we should all beware of promises that seem too good to be true – because they usually are. Farage’s brand of populism exploits justified anger, but offers little more than slogans. You – we – deserve better that that.
I know from my days working in government that it’s easy to promise the impossible and much harder to deliver meaningful change. Real progress comes from sustained efforts, practical solutions, and accountability – not reheated slogans designed only to win votes or headlines.
Nigel Farage has built a career out of making seductive promises. But, when those promises fail – as they inevitably do – we know he just moves on, leaving the rest of us to pick up the pieces. Don’t let’s fall into his trap again.
There is REAL power in informed scepticism and critical thinking. We all HAVE that power and we ALL need to use it to ensure Farage and his wealthy mates are not able to manipulate their way into positions of real power.
We are very grateful to Open Britain for allowing us to reproduce this article and it is typical of their ethos that they are happy to do so. Please subscribe to us and to Ugly Politix. We share the same values and aims.
Open Britain established the Ugly Politix channel to provide ordinary people with the information and perspective they need to pick their way past these Farage traps, part of our wider work to build a politics that genuinely works for everyone, not just those with the most money or the loudest voices in the media.
If you haven’t subscribed already, please consider doing so – it’s free!. (UGLY POLITIX subscriptions are free because, like West Country Voices, the creators don’t believe democracy should ever be behind a paywall. Voluntary paid subscriptions ARE available for those who wish to help them grow the channel, but they are precisely that…voluntary.)
